Saturday, 21 Nov, 2026
IndiaTracker.in
Economy 20-Nov, 2026

What tighter state budgets mean for India’s growth prospects

By: Team India Tracker

What tighter state budgets mean for India’s growth prospects

Photo courtesy: Pixabay 

States are seeking to contain deficits as welfare spending rises and tax revenue growth slows. The challenge is to maintain fiscal discipline without squeezing capital investment or compromising social commitments

State governments face a difficult fiscal choice. They must honour growing welfare commitments, meet the rising cost of public services and invest in infrastructure, all without allowing deficits to spiral. The numbers suggest that they are trying to exercise restraint. But a lower deficit will mean little if the effort to balance budgets comes at the expense of investment that creates jobs, raises productivity and supports future growth. 

The combined fiscal deficit of states, excluding interest-free loans from the Centre for capital expenditure, is budgeted to fall to 2.9 per cent of GDP in FY27, from 3.4 per cent in the FY26 revised estimates (RE). The figure is within the 3 per cent limit recommended by the 16th Finance Commission, according to a report by PRS Legislative Research released on Tuesday. 

The aggregate, however, conceals considerable differences. Nine states—Andhra Pradesh, Himachal Pradesh, Jammu & Kashmir, Keralam, Meghalaya, Nagaland, Punjab, Sikkim and Uttarakhand—have budgeted deficits above the recommended limit. Jammu & Kashmir has the highest deficit, at 3.7 per cent of GSDP, followed by Meghalaya and Himachal Pradesh at around 3.5 per cent each. Nagaland is marginally above the limit at 3.0005 per cent. Manipur, in contrast, has budgeted a fiscal surplus of 0.8 per cent of GSDP. 

When loans under the Centre’s Scheme for Special Assistance to States for Capital Investment (SASCI) are included, the combined deficit is estimated at 3.2 per cent of GDP in FY27, against 3.8 per cent in FY26 RE. The scheme provides 50-year interest-free loans for capital expenditure. These are excluded when calculating states’ borrowing limits, although they remain liabilities to be repaid. 

The investment test 

The scale of state spending makes the quality of these decisions important. States are expected to spend Rs 68.79 lakh crore in FY27, around 62 per cent more than the Centre’s budgeted expenditure of Rs 42.53 lakh crore. Of this, Rs 56.36 lakh crore is revenue expenditure and Rs 12.43 lakh crore capital expenditure. 

There is reason for optimism on investment. Capital expenditure is projected to grow at an annualised rate of 20 per cent between FY25 and FY27, compared with 13 per cent for revenue expenditure. Spending on roads, transport, irrigation and other infrastructure can lower costs for businesses, improve connectivity and create employment. It can also encourage private investment. Protecting this spending should be a priority, particularly when private investment remains sensitive to demand and the availability of infrastructure. 

The pressure comes from the growing cost of recurring commitments. States have budgeted around Rs 4 lakh crore for unconditional cash transfers (UCTs) in FY27, equivalent to 1 per cent of GDP, against 0.6 per cent in FY23. These schemes cover women, farmers, young people and social security pension beneficiaries, including the elderly, widows and persons with disabilities. Punjab has introduced a cash transfer scheme for women in FY27, while Keralam and West Bengal have increased allocations. 

The PRS estimate is based on 128 identified schemes and is not exhaustive; actual spending could be higher. The increase reflects both new schemes and larger allocations to existing ones. 

The welfare burden 

Cash transfers can help households meet immediate needs and supplement incomes. Subsidies, by contrast, lower the price of goods and services, though they can also encourage excessive consumption. Direct transfers allow beneficiaries to buy or produce goods and services without changing market prices. But weak targeting can send public money to unintended recipients. 

The question, therefore, is not whether welfare spending is justified. It is whether states can finance it without weakening their capacity to provide essential services and build infrastructure. Since FY23, revenue expenditure has grown faster than revenue receipts, largely because of rising subsidies and transfers. The aggregate revenue deficit, which had narrowed to 0.23 per cent of GDP in FY23, widened to 0.61 per cent in FY25 and is estimated at 0.71 per cent in FY26. 

Transfers to women and social security pensioners account for the largest share of FY27 UCT spending. Fourteen states have budgeted to spend more than three-fourths of their total UCT allocation on social security pension schemes. These commitments provide support to vulnerable households, but they also create recurring expenditure that cannot easily be withdrawn. 

The revenue constraint 

The ability to sustain such spending depends on tax collections. States derive 71 per cent of their GST revenue from SGST collections and their share of central GST through the devolution of 41 per cent of CGST. Yet SGST revenue growth slowed relative to GDP growth in FY26 for the first time in four years. 

GST collections, excluding the compensation cess, grew 5 per cent between October and March FY26, against 9 per cent in April-September, following the GST Council’s rate rationalisation in September 2025. 

The 16th Finance Commission has revised the tax devolution formula, with Karnataka, Keralam, Gujarat and Maharashtra set to receive higher shares. Contribution to national GDP is a new criterion, with a weight of 10 per cent. This favours states that account for a larger share of national output. 

There is another potential pressure on state budgets. States are estimated to spend around Rs 33,000 crore under VB-G RAM G in FY26, nearly six times the ₹5,261 crore actually spent under MGNREGA, assuming the same number of person-days and wage rates. 

The lesson is not that states should spend less on welfare or borrow more freely. It is that every recurring commitment must be weighed against the investment and public services that future growth requires. Better targeting, stronger revenue mobilisation and careful scrutiny of expenditure can help reconcile these competing demands. Fiscal discipline should not become an exercise in meeting a deficit target at any cost. Its purpose is to leave governments with the resources to build infrastructure, improve public services and expand economic opportunity. That is the measure of sound state finances. 

Share: